NYTimes David Pogue’s Best Compact Cameras under $300

NYTimes David Pogue has a great sense for value - and this year’s choices for the best compact camera for under $300 are as usual quite good. As seen in this very helpful chart, 10MPixel or better storage and some prices well under $300 rule the roost.  Many of David’s recommended cameras have 10x zoom, several have HD video and many use SD cards and some have 24mm wide angle but only one has the choice of manual/aperture priority/shutter priority shooting.  My point - for $50 more users can get compact cameras with all of these features plus light weight and thin size, advanced image exposure, improved auto-focus, plus a neat collection of individual attractions like advanced burst mode exposures or GPS/Compass recording and display capabilities. So do read David’s best, but also take a glance at the top of the line compacts for $350.

Bookmark and Share

3 Next-generation Compact Cameras

As a photo-artist I really appreciate always having a camera with me. Rather than taking a bulky, heavy SLR everywhere I have reverted back to compact cameras because they are certainly delivering on thin, light, wide zoom-range and gobs of features. They are also bound and determined not to provide a view finder - to my chagrin.

But the LED viewing/composing screens on the back are getting ever better. And now that HD video is on board so is multiple fast exposures. And most cameras provide at least 10MPixels and 10x zoom so there is a lot to like as portability with lots of picture taking power becomes ever better. And the new compact cameras are a real leg up on using smartphones with their tiny sensors and cramped, coke bottle lensing. So here are three compact cameras, two of which were at the CES 2010 show which show very great promise for the price:

1)Sony Cybershot HX5V/B - $350, 10MPixels, 10x zoom, 171grams

To these capabilities Sony has added a rich set of goodies including HD video clips at 1920 x 1080p using either AVCHD or storage efficient MP4 recording format, four anti-blur functions, and GPS capabilities - the camera records not just the time and date when the picture was taken but also its location and direction of shooting with an on board compass - orienteering people take note.

My 3 favorite new goodies are burst mode of 10 frames per second so you never miss that action shot. The Sony people have taken this capability a step further with the Panorama Sweep Mode. Press the shutter and sweep - then the camera does the rest, continuously shooting images and in one second stitching them together. Second, the camera takes face recognition to a new level with anti-blink detection and Smile recognition. Now all you have to do is coax the subject to relax and enjoy their portrait. Third, there is Transfer jet Technology which allows transferring up to 10 files by just touching two devices together. Most of the major camera makers are on board - Canon, Casio, Eastman Kodak, Hitachi Ltd, JVC-Kenwood Holdings, KDDI, NEC, Nikon, NTT docomo, Olympus, Panasonic, Pioneer, Samsung, Seiko Epson, Sharp, SoftBank Mobile, Sony, and Toshiba. The speed is about 35 MB second and the demo was impressive; but I am from Missouri on this, the Motion Detection,  and in camera Photo editing functions. You and I will have to wait until mid March this year to test out these features. But boy I wish the Sony SLRs could get some of these smarts. Oh and perhaps most important of all, the Cybershot HX5 supports industry standard SD/SDHC cards.

2)Samsung HZ35W - $350??, 12MPixels, 15xzoom, 245grams with battery and SC/SDHC card

Like the Sony Cybershot, the Samsung HZ35W has video but at 720P and 30fps with HDMI or USB connector and H.264 compression. It also has GPS capabilities and takes them a couple steps further than Sony. There is in-camera software for displaying saved images on a map interface so that users can in effect use the camera as a record of when and how pictures were taken - and as a live GPS compass.

Meanwhile The 3″ AMOLED screen [much better visibility in direct sunlight] not only shows GEO tags and maps but also delivers truer colors while reducing battery drain. The 15x zoom is tops in this compact camera field with equivalent of a 24-360mm SLR range.

Finally, the Samsung provides greater camera control - with manual mode, aperture priority and shutter priority as well as a choice of ISO 80-3200, shutter 16sec- 1/2000sec, and f3.2 to f9.8. This is coupled with 2 auto-focus corrections and 8 major picture taking modes. The one problem is that Samung has not decided on a price for the cameras debut at the end of March 2010 - the lower bound is the $280 price of Samsung TL105.

To this camera buff the great zoom and camera control options make the HZ35W a real contender depending on how that AMOLED screen performs and the final pricing.

3)Casio EXILIM EX-FH100 - $350, 10x zoom, 10MPixel, 181grams without battery

The CASIO EX-FH100 looks a lot like the Sony Cybershot in its key specs. However it does not have the Cybershot’s GPS feature and can only do HD at 1280 x 720p at 30 fps [ but also can do a range of small sizes from 640 x 480 at 120fps to 224 x 64 1000fps]. And its high speed exposure capability is carried into the still image taking where the camera can take 30 shots at 9MPixels shooting from 2fps to 30fps [user selected]. Given that the camera already has two auto focus correction systems, the sharpness of the image is enhanced by Best Shot Option that automatically selects the best image from burst exposures depending on what shooting mode is chosen.

The Casio EX-FH100 uses its burst mode operation coupled with its fast image processor to merge with the flash combining two or more images into one evenly lighted shot. Likewise the camera does auto-HDR combinations of 3 images shot at user selected ev intervals to get the best possible highlight and shadow areas combined into one image. This smart burst-shot technology is combined with a back illuminated CMOS sensor to provide a total 10 Best Shot modes of operation.

Having used the Casio EX-FH1 for the past two years, I am anxious to tryout the EX-FH100 in mid-March when the camera goes on sale. My contacts say that the Best Shot modes, new camera raw format, and 9MPixels [versus 5MPixels for the my EX-FH1] makes for outstanding image taking. I am anxious to confirm that.

Summary

Although these three cameras each have very similar basic profile [and for me that is light, thin, and fit in a shirt pocket], each has its own special attractions. I will definitely be at the camera stores in March and April to give readers an update on the performance of each of these compact cameras. I am from Missouri, so I have to see for myself how well these cameras perform before I give the final review on what appears to be 3 great mobile cameras.

Bookmark and Share

Comments on Apples iPad

The comments on Apple’s iPad are starting to really roll in the best I have found so far is by New York Times David Pogue:

* Like the iPhone, the iPad is really a vessel, a tool, a 1.5-pound sack of potential. It may become many things.

This catches the overall theme of many gadget observers. The offering is not complete but as an eReader it beats the Kindle hands down and as a media viewer it has many advantages but the distinct liability of not supporting Adobe’s Flash . But I get ahead of others:
NYTimes - Three reasons why the iPad will kill the Kindle [but not the Kindle bookstore]
Engadget - many writers at Engadget reach a consensus:  iPad as delivered is distinctly flawed
Guardian - bloggers around the world bash the iPad - and then provides links
CNET -iPad unites Apple’s media and mobile ambitions
Cnet again
- Apple’s iPad touches a nerve in Redmond.
PCWorld
-  10 big  mistakes in the iPad
Clearly iPad is not seen as an unbridled second coming success - rather its seen as fledgling with possibilities. Or not a Microsoft Vista more like the first iPhone. Lets see how fast iPad triangulates towards what the market readers/leaders want.

Bookmark and Share

Photofinishing Resources


Evocowire is the strange name of a website crammed with photofinishing resources and tutorials. Most of the resources like the actions shown in the picture above are for PhotoShop - sets of actions, brushes, and templates abound on the site - and they are topnotch. But there are also resources for Paint Shop Pro, Adobe Illustrator and a few other graphics software programs. As well, Evocowire has tutorials and news. It appears the site is new but judging from the standards so far, I hope this website really prospers.

Bookmark and Share

Online PhotoFinishing


Online Photo-Editing sites have been covered by thePhotoFinishes.com before; but not a free online PhotoFinishing site. Befunky changes that - it is devoted to taking your photos and transforming them into works of art using special effects like Cartoonizer, Oil Painting, Inkify, Old Photo, Charcoal, Impressionist, and my favorite - PopArt. Then add some goodies. Its free to try and if you register, you can save and/or share your works. $50/year you get the full range of special effects, support for giant images, plus no befunky.com watermark in the lower right corner. For $250/year you can sell your works of befunkey-ized art.

Befunky is easy to try yourself - navigate to befunky.com and upload an image and for free, you can be the next Andy Warhol. There are some downsides - only one effect can be applied to an image [no combining effects] - but there are 2 or 3 user customized settings to each effect. Also there is no way to mask or create layers for more “finished” photo effects [take a look at www.fotoflexer.com for these capabilities plus a new set of special effects]. Befunky won’t make a badly composed shot look good, but will save a good shot slightly off focus, color shifted or in need of a little cropping and styling. Try it, you may like it a lot.

Bookmark and Share

Color Concerto - Try 27 Best Color Websites Live

One of the advantages of the Web 2.0 RIA revolution is that Flash and JavaScript websites are not only getting more features but also much faster in performance. Color Wheels and Color Chooser websites have gotten very sophisticated. Going to my old wheel favorite Color Scheme Designer I could not find it - it has a new and faster edition. But then I discovered I had lost all my color bookmarks. So I decided to collect all may favorites together in a series of live websites links so they are convenient for me and for Picthat readers. These are all live websites, so you can try them out directly. And when you find colorful site that catches your fancy - just click on the link or right mouse click to go directly to the color site in its own browser window:


5 Color Theory Websites


6 Color Wheel Tools


7 Color Chooser from Images Tools


5 Quirky Color Tools


5 Color Testing Tools

Finally all in one place for convenient decision which is best for current task and then go! If you have a favorite you don’t see here - just add a comment.

Bookmark and Share

CES Citings: Canon EOS 1D Mark IV

After its annoucement in October 2009,  Canon EOS 1D Mark IV went underground with the ability to acquire one severely taxed. So Canon may be taking advanatge of CES - Consumer Electronics Show 2010 in Las Vegas to relaunch the camera with its imminent greater availability.  Canon is locked in a battle with Nikon’s D3S at $5000 retail for lead in the Pro camera high ISO, fast+accurate autofocus contest [for stills, both cameras offer video capture but not with auto-focus].

The specs for the Canon 1D Mark IV are impressive:
>ISO 50 to 102,400 with sharp, noise free up to ISO 6400
>45 autofocus sensors with fast dual processor   rendering
>1080P video at 24, 28, 30fps using .MOV file storage
>3″ 920,000 pixel LCD panel
>Wifi connectivity as option

But the lack of cameras for preview is evidenced by no final review at popular camera websites like  DPreview.
So here is the Canon promo:

Bookmark and Share

CES Citing: Ski, Scuba, Swimming Goggles

Liquid Image has ski, scuba, and swimming goggles which take still pictures[2200 images on one battery charge] and video images at 720 x 480 [2 hours worth on one battery charge ]. The google will be available this summer at $149US without the 16GB SD card. So plan on $200+ expenditure with taxes. There are mode and snap/click controls on the goggle’s bands and dispaly of the goggles state on the goggle windows at the sides. The scuba version is an update from an earlier model - see here for details.

Talk about still and video cameras appearing in new modes - here is a natural for sports enthusiasts. Beats taking the mobile phone to the slopes.

Bookmark and Share

CES Becomes PhotoKina?

The CES Electronic Gadget show in Las Vegas has started to win back big annoucements in the photo world. Normally photo buffs would have to wait for PhotoKina for the really heavyweight photo announcements. But how do you like this for heft:

Leica announces $31,000 body-only S2-P


Stay tuned for more camera goodies from CES.

Bookmark and Share

Web 2.0 GUI Better than Desktop

With the full flower of RIA-Rich Internet Applications [think DHTML and Flash tecnologies] Web GUI is starting match those available on the desktop - be that Windows 7 with its Aero goodies or Apple Snow Leopard with its refined look and often copied navigational features. Here is an example from Adobe PDFs - the electronic container of choice for illustrators and artists. Let me show you a PDF on the Web as powered by Issuu.com:

Here is another example. Now just below is a screenshot of a Windows desktop displaying the same PDF in the desktop Acrobat 8.10 reader using the default features:

What Issuu.com has done in refining PDF’s presentation on the Web is to improve on the presentation side with nicer navigational and control features. Even if one looks at Acrobat.com and notes whats Adobe has made available there, the comparison is in favor of Issuu.com - here is a screen shot of the same PDF at Acrobat.com:


Now some will argue that drag and drop, multi-touch with gestures, and vector or bitmap drawing are still not available on the Web. But that is changing. SVG for vector drawing is available from Firefox and Opera; and will be part of the HTML 5 spec which also brings bitmap drawing to the Web. Gestures has been a part of Opera for a longtime while most popular JavaScript frameworks deliver drag and drop capabilities that are fairly simple to program.

Here are the two leading RIA technologies that photofinishers and designer will want to follow closely. Flash/Flex/Air from Adobe got a big win with the release of the NYTimes offline/online Digital Paper Reader[ see here for details]. This technology demonstrates the power of Flash media delivery and offline operations.
Web 2.0 DHTML=HTML+CSS+JavaScript is the other RIA leader. Apple, Firefox, Google and Opera are all pushing browser technology so fast that Microsoft Internet Explorer is being left way behind. Also the HTML5 stanadrd as seen above has pushed the state of the browser art.
Microsoft Silverlight is tragically flawed with its proprietary extensions, “Must run best in Windows” philosophy, and the incomplete cross platform and cross browser support.

In sum, be aware of what is rapidly being made available in the RIA arena - Web 2.0 and Cloud Computing is coming to the design and photo worlds.

Bookmark and Share

PacMan

Another Example of “free” widgets - this one from Google. They have 2000 of these.

Bookmark and Share

PDF’s Done with Panache

Issuu.com is more than a website for publishing your PDFs - it takes displaying Adobes PDF’s to anew level. And it shows how to display PDFs with the greatest panache:

Now as Honourable Father would say - “How do you like them marbles??”

Bookmark and Share

A Google Flickr Viewer

Alas poor Yorick I am hung! This routine is taking so much time to load I will have to send you to identically the same code works stored as separate file on the server over here. The thumbnails look pretty bad - even at a 240Px width size. You would think Google could do better.

Bookmark and Share

A New Image Viewer

There is an absolute flood of image viewers and slideshow scripts that one can add to a website or blog - here is one from TripTracker that seem rather nifty and clean and most important, fast:

For Slideshow-Click Me
detail of mask
See me in the show

The virtues of this slideshow viewer is the simplicity of its implementation and the ability to handle image files of many varying dimensions. Kudos to TripTracker.

Bookmark and Share

Whats Missing in Compact Cameras?


This is the Canon Powershot SD880 but whats missing here is also missing on my Panasonic Lumix Tz3 - a view finder. Now I can live with a compact camera that has a paltry manual mode settings range of f4.5 to f12 for for f-stop settings and shutter speed range of 1/60th to 1/500th - or none at all. I also can live with a compact camera that does not allow me to add location or note tags except by writing directly on the image. And I can live with a camera that makes white balance/image temperature corrections an obscure operational sequence equivalent to programming your TV with its button befuddling remote.

But I am now officially putting SHOWSTOPPER on any compact camera that does not have a viewfinder. Even with my Lumix pumped to the brightest battery-eating setting I can barely see the LCD screen on even modestly sunny days. Worse - at the Car Show the brights eclipsed the LCD screen.

Now Canon has a Powershot SD890 as seen below:

The optical zoom is 5x instead of 4x on the SD880, the image is equivalent at 10MPixel - and there is a viewfinder. And the price is $300 less on Amazon [but hey, I have found Amazon camera prices not always reflective of what's best in the market]. Unfortunately, I am seeing more very good compact cameras coming out with no viewfinder. Don’t make the mistake that I did - assuming the in-the-camera shop LCD screen will work out in the bright lights of an ordinary sunny day.

Bookmark and Share

SSD-Solid State Drives for Digital Cameras/Camcorders; Update Nov 2009

Update: the price per gigabyte for a HDD has sunk to $0.07/GB in approximately a year and a half. Also see this comparison of HDD vs SSD trade-offs. But the most important trend is a slowdown in SSD drive cost/GB reductions forecast out to 2014. The improvements in cost/GB have already started to slow and will continue to do so. This means that the current $2/GB for SSD will see only modest reduction [versus past historical trends] to $0.20-0.50/GB by 2014. This averages at about 3 to 7 times current HDD drive prices. So what is becoming apparent is that HDD drives will become like backup Tape Drives for SSD drives. I have already bought a 1TB $100Can external drive as back up for my digital still and video images. However, my wait for a digital camera with a large, fast, and cheap SSD is on hold.


The original story is posted below with NO Editing of any data. Original was posted March 27, 2008


What you see above is a 256GB SSD - Solid State Drive. It has a capacity of 256GB and has an average access speed of 0.1ms. I have highlighted in yellow some of its other important operating specs. Lets compare this SSD to a regular hard disk drive-HDD used in most PCs, but less often in notebooks and laptops at 7200RPM [most laptop HDDs are at 5400RPM because they are more reliable]. Both drives will use a standard SATA connection to the device. The HDD-Hard Disk Drive will be a 7200RPM, 3.5″ drive used in some top-end laptops(better performer is placed first):
Maximum capacity - HDD 1000GB, SSD-850GB - not much difference here
Average Access Time - SSD 0.1ms, HDD-7MS - huge 70x speed advantage to SSD
Transfer Rate - HDD-75MB/sec, SSD-50-65/MB/sec - HDD has 15-20% faster data movement rate
MTBF - SSD 1Million hours, HDD - .6Million - advantage to SSD but note cautions below
Cost - HDD $1/GB, SSD $10-15/GB - decided advantage to HDD
So in just these five factors one can see the major trade-offs between HDD-Hard Disk Drives and SSD as used in photo equipment.

However there are some secondary factors to take into account. First, the technologies in SSD using Flash memory are relatively new where as HDD technology is at least 40 years old. Second there are some performance characteristics harder to quantify comparatively that give additional advanatges to SSD. Power consumption for SSD drives is 30-80% lower than HDD giving longer battery life and less heat. The SSD has virtually no noise. And finally the SSD is much better able to stand falls and high G force shocks than a hard disk. That is why SSDs are used in military and industrial applications.

On the downside for Flash-memory based SSD which have been used throughout this note is the fact that repeated writes to a memory cell in a Flash memory device can lead to write failures. Typically, the failure occurs after 1–5 million write cycles (for high usage files such as log files, file allocation tables, and other commonly used parts of the file system exceed this over the lifetime of a typical computer). However, new write leveling algorithms are improving this factor.

So HDD disk drives are already appearing in laptops (new MacBook air and the OLPC-One Laptop Per Child). Likewise in photo equipment both highend camcorders and SLR digital cameras are using SSD. It appears the constraint for wider usage of SSD will be the cost per GB and some other competing technologies like compact flash cards and more importantly SDHC cards popular in many point and shoot cameras, digital SLRs, camcorders and even laptops.

See here for a comparison of SSD versus the popular SDHC memory modules used in many digital cameras and camcorders. Again this trade-off between SDHC and SSD is a cost (advantage of about 8 to 1 for SDHC) versus speed and capacity (advantage of about 4 to 1 in both cases for SSD); however with both technologies have better reliability over HDD based devices.

Summary

Expect your digital camera and especially camcorders to add impressive speed and capacity in the next few years
through both SSD drives. But also expect faster SDHC cards used in both digital cameras and camcorders. What does this mean to you the photo enthusiast? Camcorders in 1-2 years time that are able to store 100-200GB and the same for Digital SLRs. Watch for more cameras that will be able to to do things like the Casio EX-F1 currently does but at longer intervals and greater base image size. Expect bracketing and sports clips at 10-30 images per second for larger than 6MPixels and longer than 3-5 second bursts. In sum, there will a lot of performance improvements in digital camera and especially camcorders in the next 1-3 years; much will be in the back end where speed and capacity of recording images will improve by big factors of 50% or more for each new product intro.

Bookmark and Share

Windows 7 Graphic PC: Weekend Benchmarks

Well we spent most of the weekend trying to figure out our benchmarks results - would Windows 7 be able to beat Windows XP in raw speed and performance? Here is that tale of the table:

Speed Comparison: Windows 7 versus Windows XP
Test Windows 7 Windows XP
Copy 800MB file from USB 29sec 27sec
Copy 800MB file to USB 59sec 52sec
Copy 800MB file to file 25sec 28sec
Copy 430MB directory USB to drive 31 sec 68sec
Create 120,000 line .sql file using PHP 6sec 12 sec
Insert 120,000 records into MySQL Table SQL 46 min 05sec 140sec
Select 120,000 records with filterand group by <1 sec < 1 sec
Insert 60,000 records into MySQL Supplier Table 24min 11sec 68sec
Insert 60,000 records into MySQL Supplier Table SQL 275sec 16sec
Insert 60,000 records into MySQL Supplier Table PHP 291sec 18sec
Left Join between Product and Supplier Tables <1 sec <1 sec
Premiere Elements Boot up 29 sec 25sec
Premiere Elements Analyze Scene 200 sec 190sec
Premiere Elements write FLV 10min clip 640 x 480 630sec 428sec
Photoshop CS3 First Boot up 14sec 12sec
Photoshop CS3-Smart Blur 14MPixel image 16sec 12sec
Photoshop CS3-Finishing Impressionist 14MPixel image 9sec 6sec
Photoshop CS3-Finishing Filter Gallery 14MPixel image 15sec 9sec
Photoshop CS3-Finishing \impressionist 24MPixel image 31sec 25sec
Photoshop CS3-Crop, Resize, Shape, Color Correct <1 sec <1 sec
Photoshop CS3-Brighteness, Exposure, Sharpen <1 sec <1 sec
Photoshop CS3-Topaz Smart Sharpen 26MPixel image 20sec 18sec
Photoshop CS3-Reshape 26MPixel image 160sec 154sec
Photoshop CS3-Texture Finishing 26MPixel image 44sec 36sec

Green shows the faster performer and red marks where the speed of a system is 2 or more times slower than the other. Two things are obvious from these benchmarks. Windows XP on a 2.26GHz Dual Core PC with 3GB of RAM plus a 250GB hard drive consistently outperforms Windows 7 on 2.10GHz Dual Core PC with 4GB of RAM plus a 500GB SATA hard drive.

Well of course Windows XP does, it has a faster CPU. Well, not exactly.

I looked up the Passmark ratings of the two CPUs and the Windows XP Dual Core is rated at 1046 while the Windows 7 is rated at 1251. So  Windows 7’s CPU should have a 19.6% speed  advantage over the Windows XP  PC - but XP  consistently outperforms Windows 7 even with 1GB less of memory available. But what is of real concern is the very poor performance of Windows 7 doing Web development tasks. PHP and MySQL ran significantly slower in Windows 7 using a XAMPP provided Apache-MySQL–PHP server combo. So I had to drag out PHPed and Xdebug to profile and debug the problems. To date I do not have any solutions or insights.

I was going to do some AutoCAD, Corel Draw, Java, JavaScript, Oracle and PostgreSQL benchmarking but the the Windows 7 problems with PHP and MySQL forced a delay in game penalty. If any readers have insights into the Windows 7 problems with PHP and/or MySQL please post a comment.

Summary of Benchmarks

On one hand Windows 7 on a Gateway with a 17.3 inch screen at $650 Canadian [before taxes] is a pleasure to work with. Users will have plenty of room to work in. And the new Windows 7 taskbar makes moving among apps a lot easier. The system had close to XP-like Boot up, Shutdown and Start-up or Hibernate restore times. And copy operations [ notably faster than XP] and open file popups are not painfully slow like in Vista. Also I have yet to run into the annoying Vista roller-coaster performance lags [bright and peppy for 20 minutes then slow as molasses in January for the next 25, then back to .....]. But I have to admit, it is galling to have to endure a 5-20% performance hit in photo and video editing when the new Windows 7 machine should be delivering the very opposite in performance.

Bookmark and Share

New Windows 7 PC for Graphics: Day 3 Review

I am still looking  for an  inexpensive fast, easy to learn photo editor. Don’t get me wrong - Adobe has the top 3 bitmap photo editors in Lightroom, Photoshop Elements and Photoshop CS4.
But all of these Adobe photo editors have 4 consistent problems with the biggest 2 being price and a huge learning curve. So with this inaugural look at Windows 7 it makes sense to look at the newly enhanced Microsoft Paint  and see how closely it fits the bill.

Basic Core Features of our Lightweight Photo Editor

Perhaps the only way to guarantee a fast start-up and fast running photo editor is to restrict its core features and that is precisely what Microsoft Paint for Windows 7 has done. So here is our core, basic editing features that we are looking for in a Lightweight Photo Editor:

0)Drag and drop images from File Manager or any other drag+drop source;
1)cropping+image resizing like in Photoshop’s Crop tool;
2)rotate, straighten, flip, perspective-fix commands like in many editors;
3)Color correction like in PaintShop Pro’s Manual Color Correction command;
4)Color Balance like in Lightroom’s Temperature, Vibrance, Saturation, Hue commands;
5)Lightness control like the Photoshop Exposure and Levels commands;
6)Image touch up like Photoshop’s Clone and Healing Brush tools;
7)Text tool like in Techsmith’s Snagit Editor;
8)Paint and fill commands like in many photo editors [no gradients or brushmaking tools];
9)Blur/commands commands like Photoshop’s Smart Blur;
10)Sharpen commands like Photoshop’s Smart Sharpen;

What is definitely off the operating list are complex graphic ops like layers/objects, animations, vector drawing commands, 3D extensions, compositing tools like panoramas and bitmap
fills into polygon surfaces, CAD rendering, etc. This is precisely what MS Paint avoids and provides:

Note the use of the MSOffice Ribbon interface with the complete set of tools and colors strung across the top of the screen. There are two tabs Home and View which change the ribbon of commands. So lets see if how well MS Paint meets our requirements for a Lightweight Photo Editor. It start off with the right price - free:

1a)Cropping - no shading, no perspective, no builtin resizing - well below par
1b)Resizing - by r absolute value, but only one method - below par
2)Rotate, flip, perspective correct - no perspective nor skew - below par
3)Manual Color correction - no tools - a showstopper deficit
4)Color balance and toning - no tools - a showstopper deficit
5)Lightness control - no tools - a showstopper deficit
6)Image touch up -several brushes, no clone or healing brush - well below par
7)Text tool - horizontal, no vertical with options - below par
8)Paint and fill commands - paint + brushes - above par; fills no gradients - below par
9)Blur/smooth commands - no tools - a showstopper deficit
10)Sharpen commands - no tools - a showstopper deficit

If you get the impression that MS Paint is sadly lacking as a LightWeight Photo Editor with 5 features simply not present - then the logical next question is what was Microsoft trying to do with MS Paint ? Create a Paint Program for Dummies, too simplistic for anything but making signs and doing elementary image crops and rotations. That appears to be the target - enhanced MS Paint seems to be an insult. So in effect, 10s of millions of new digital camera users will be saying to Microsoft - “thanks for nothing”. Very strange for a company that makes at least $80 for every new copy of Windows 7 Home Premium sold. MSPaint is just fodder for another Mocking Mac TV Commercial.

Bookmark and Share

New Windows 7 PC for Graphics:The Experience Day 2

What becomes immediately evident working with a Gateway NV74 with a 17.3″ screen in Windows 7 is that its is lovely to have so much extra room -  now there is plenty for PS panels:

The response time seems reasonable but I shall have detailed comparisons by days end hopefully. One complaint on the keyboard - it is a large layout as well except for the Left Shift key which is only the size of a regular key . So \\i <== I keep doing this while typing, hitting the neighboring Backslash key, when I want to hit caps.

I have spent some degree of time making the following replacements:
Notepad++ for Windows 7 Notepad
UltraExplorer for Windows 7 Explorer
IZarc for the the Zip file facility in Windows 7 Explorer
Filezilla for FTP operations not prominently supported in Windows 7
Given the above a)are free software and b)much superior to what Windows 7 provides- Microsoft should contribute $5-10M to each vendor[the cost of a ten person development team for 2 years to produce the equivalent software to say nothing of the $100 of millions saved because Windows users did not desert the OS because the Redmond offerings were so ...uh "feature deprived"].

Bookmark and Share

New Windows 7 PC for Graphics:The Experience

Well a graphics-oriented  client currently running Windows XP wants to try to make the transition to Windows 7 from XP - so I have been commissioned to test out a Gateway NV74 17.3″ 4GB RAM,  500GB hard disk@5400RPM  [Passmark rating of 1.243]. The OS is Windows 7 Home Premium. I  think this PC Model and OS was chosen  because it costs $649 rather than $1500 to $2000  required for the “equivalent” Apple Macs; but I could be wrong on this impression.

The Windows 7 machine took 31 minutes to boot-up and set up including all security updates but no additional program loads. In effect the PC with Windows 7 was operating and I got to choose the bulk of the additional downloads and program installs. And I chose none.  However, Gateway did reserve first boot upDesktop Real Estate Rights to the following vendors:
Norton Internet Security 2009
Norton Online Backup
Google iGoogle
Ebay
Gateway Free Trial games
Microsoft Office Try, Buy or Activate
Microsoft Works
Net Zero Internet Access
Nonetheless, the setup operations performed essentially hands and attention free and no excessive program installs were allowed. So the first test was to load some large image  and data files from a USB card drive and then process the images using Photoshop CS4. But first, I had to download and install Adobe Photoshop CS4.

And that is when the problems started.

Adobe use Akamai Download Manager. And Windows 7 could not/would not recognize the Akamai delivered executable file. So Windows 7 slapped a lock on the file and made it invisible to Windows Explorer.

Now I had been told that Windows 7 had much improved versions of Windows Explorer and Notepad . Not exactly… and I was starting to have problems finding any of my files. So I finally gave up looking for the files and used Internet Explorer to download and install UltraExplorer - a much more adept and free file manager for Windows 7. Unlike Win Explorer, Ultra Explorer could see the files:

But let me assure you that Windows 7 contrived no matter what permissions I used to, to frustrate any attempts to unlock the downloaded .7z file. However, in stark contrast, Windows XP had no problems seeing and using the downloaded files. So a new plan was spawned - just move the Adobe Photoshop trial edition file over from the Windows XP to Windows 7. I got the files over but still Windows 7 said NO PERMISSO!!.
So after 4 hours of work I will try another approach - loading Photoshop CS3 from the install DVDs. Stay tuned for more adventures with the New and Improved Windows 7 as applied to graphics.

Bookmark and Share